Hall of Shame: 
* Jim Mathers - $cientology "OT VIII"
* Mark Plummer - "ex"-$cientologist cyber-bully
* The David Miscavige Texts (NEW ADDITION - the text just days before Christy died in the hospital)
* Aaron Smith-Levin covers up for David Miscavige - Aaron's panic-defense videos DEBUNKED
* Facebook Victim Shaming - screenshots of the unrepentant

Jim Mathers:

Victim Shaming Is No Joke

Jim Mathers - $cientology "OT VIII"

Jim Mathers - $cientology "OT VIII" - Multi-Millionaire Donor

In 2020, a $cientology "OT VIII" multi-millionaire was recruited by his friend and church leader David Miscavige to harass Christy W. after going public in 2019 with claims of multiple rapes at the hands of David Miscavige and selected others, during her childhood and teenage years.

Jim Mathers was the "OT VIII" chosen for the job.  He perhaps believes David Miscavige is innocent of the crimes reported on this website, but his actions went so far over the line (we wonder what his wife would think...)

---

Jim Mathers & Wife - Does She Know?

The purple shirt is important, because it links him with one of many "penes" (Spanish for you know what...) shots (only some will be included here, appropriately de-focused) and gives the viewer pretty direct evidence that this is in the same series sent to Christy's cellphone, along with threats and harassing comments not befitting an "OT VIII" (highest level attainable in David Miscavige's version of the Church of $cientology).

(...and anyway ...isn't this illegal?)

Again, we're having to focus-edit the photos because they are too disgusting for publication.  He sent these in 2020 by phone chat to Christy W, in an effort to harass her and shudder her into silence for going public with what happened to her at the hands of David Miscavige.

---

Creepy Jim's Idea of an Introduction?

Oh, So That's What This Is About...(?)

Okay, Here Comes the Sexual Advances...

Jim Mathers Getting Ready? For What?

Oh No!!! Jim Mathers is Not Talking to His Wife Here...

Oops! Is That the Same Purple Shirt and Hairy Tummy We Just Saw Above??? YUCK!!!

YES, That IS Jim Mathers' same Purple shirt - (and we saved You having to look at the really nasty ones... You're Welcome.)

Meet Mark Plummer

who posts as "Warrior" over at the
Ex-Scientologists Message Board (ESMB)



He sent his wife to harass Scott Gordon (the author of this website) within days after another Facebook chat (supposedly private between Christy and I - so I would suggest that David Miscavige has some protectors in high places).  I'm not saying that Donna Reott knows exactly why she's sent to harass me, but we're not friends, and I hadn't been anywhere near her or her husband, on or off-line.  First of all, let's look at the moment Christy finally realizes how seriously David Miscavige takes the covering up of his brutal rapes of her...

---

This is the Historic Moment (11-29-2022) when Christy first realizes the Hit & Run was an attempt to Kill her - A new project is born (which leads to the creation of this website)

Note the Date of the new chat a full Nine Months after the first chat, (ever, with her) - She approaches me only ten days after Christy and I are into "Secretly" proceeding with Documenting Her Case over Facebook Chat - (At this point no one else knows but Facebook Computers!)

Mark Plummer with Tony Ortega - for More to Their Story, Right-Click and "Open in New Tab" the Following Link: https://WatchfulNavigator.wordpress.com/2019/03/16/the-intelligence-troika-of-the-controlled-opposition-cientology-cover-up/

Now comes an important moment to make some connections, because it's been undisputed by those in my circles, that Mark Plummer operates a fake Facebook account, somewhat useful in the intelligence world as a "honeypot" profile, which fake person has set up an e-mail address for reporting to a "public service" site ("Fakes & Scammers") which claims to identify fake profiles and scammers (many of whom steal porn-star photos, to attract men, as the Regina Anderrson account has).

Looks like a "helpful public service" - but is there an intelligence-gathering angle here?

This Turns Out to Actually Be Mark Plummer (and Christy Knew This Before I Did!)

For those who frown at taking my word for it connecting the Mark Plummer and Regina Andersson accounts, here's one of the groups ("Nextdoor where free speech reigns") that they run together.

Christy asks Why He/She is sending her this...(?)

Rape-Shaming by Mark Plummer

Christy Receives a Hostile, Shaming Message from Mark Plummer, Who of All Things is Harassing Her About Using a "Fake" Name (Which is Actually a Shortened Version to Protect Her Privacy)

Christy has severe physical reactions from the bullying and harassment. The goal is, as once mentioned by L. Ron Hubbard, to "shudder the person into silence." So far, this had been achieved. Until now...

Mark Plummer's Chosen Facebook Image

Why would Mark Plummer be doing a thing like this? - bothering a victim of the leader of the Church of $cientology?

---

The David Miscavige Texts


New - Sent August 2023 - Just Days Before Christy Died - Spoofed? - A Hoax?

This brings us back to our perpetrator and serial rapist, David Miscavige, Chairman of the Board of the $cientology corporation.

He began sending Christy text messages through an anonymous re-mailer, in order that they would not (he hoped) ever connect back to him.

The problem is that the signature style - already revealed in the past by his past assistants, Mark Rathbun and Mike Rinder - is unmistakable.  He uses angry, nasty language when he speaks to his own team, let alone a person he is out to destroy.

"WE OWN YOU!!!" is a common $cientology management dramatization.  It was run on me as Director of Special Affairs, Celebrity Centre Dallas.  It was screamed at me over the phone numerous times.  From the looks of it, this comes from David Miscavige.

If you want to read these text messages, you do so on your own responsibility.  They are not for everyone, and they will be placed in "gallery" mode so they are not as likely to sit on a screen to get anyone in trouble.  You will have to dig through and download the images if you need them (attention: law enforcement). 

This is EXTREME rape shaming and a look into the mind of a rapist.

WARNING!!! - I will say it again.  These are NASTY!

---

This is the only undated text, but it fits in with the others and is typical of his attitude. Total invalidation of Christy as brutal bullying of a person he already tried to kill.

Christy can have no idea of the whereabouts and condition of her older sons, and what happened here.

"No one will ever believe you" is the abuser's hopeful cry. But many now believe and can see what was done, and how evil it was and still is.

Don't blame us for David Miscavige's spelling mistake here. Christy bore one daughter, which infuriated David Miscavige and she has no idea what happened to her after she was taken away the next day.

Aaron Smith-Levine Effectively Protecting David Miscavige Using His YouTube Channel - Claiming to "De-Bunk" Christy's Story

Aaron Smith-Levin (left) pictured with his Clearwater, Florida neighbor and Leah Remini show co-star Mike Rinder (who according to Christy, was personally involved in holding her captive)

Aaron Smith-Levin is a popular you-tube broadcaster with his channel, "Growing Up in Scientology."  It's quite probable that his neighbor Mike Rinder has never clued him in on Mike's participation in holding Christy captive as a teenager and young adult before her escape. 

Aaron devoted two lengthy shows pretending to "debunk" Christy's story told to John McGhee and released on video (transcribed on the INTERVIEWS tab of this website), starting with the flimsiest of arguments in the first one:

• assuming that a child could not have been smuggled onto International Base, but then admitting Sea Org members were still allowed to have children back then, so children were in fact, present on the base
• mocking Christy for not having the presence of mind to "clarify" a call for a statement John McGhee had put to her in the video implying "the executives" (plural) knew, simply because Christy was not ready to state on video the names of those few who knew - this Aaron uses as ammunition against her story (and will go all-out on this point in his next video) since it is pretty obvious that multiple executives leaving the church would not have stayed quiet about it - only the participants would have (see main page for her naming of Mike Rinder, Shelly Miscavige and Marty Rathbun)
• this leads Aaron into a lengthy diatribe in defense of Mike Rinder, over having his name mentioned - launching personal attacks against John McGhee in a strained effort to discredit him and even to blame people like him for discrediting valid $cientology criticism that could have "saved him joining the Sea Org" (long, off-topic rant that goes on the last half of the video)

[Note that it is true that Christy has had a very hard time writing her very first, ever, sequential narratives, and also in staying on-topic, to answer questions she is asked, whether in writing or verbally.  This is not because she is being inventive, but because the trauma of trying to express herself and tell her story has so far proven too overwhelming. - SG]

In the second video where Aaron interviews David Miscavige's father, Ron Miscavige, Sr. (now deceased), he introduces Christy as "the lady who for the last three years has been attempting to 'sell' her story to the Washington Post, the Tampa Bay Times, Tony Ortega, and any former Scientologist she can find..."

Again, no reasonable arguments were put forth to "debunk" Christy's story, although Ron could have used his experiential knowledge of International Base (that Aaron did not have) to at least attempt to do so.

Instead, Ron Miscavige opened his response by making the vicious suggestion that Christy "give herself an item" ($cientology term) and "go to a mirror and say, 'I'm nuts'."  And so in this second video attempt to "debunk" Christy's story, Aaron leads the viewers even further astray:

• no serious effort to "debunk" her story is made, but both Aaron and Ron engage in derogatory and sarcastic attacks on Christy's credibility with no real arguments advanced (note that Ron Miscavige, Sr. is a man who admitted to raping at least one woman and was formally accused of raping more than one woman)
• Aaron incorrectly argues that such a thing would have been "reported internally" (as if David Miscavige or anyone who knew would have filed written reports on the matter).
• Aaron asserts that since Christy has said both, "five kids" (the sons she got to nurse before they were taken) and "six kids" (counting an infant girl taken away the next day after birth and never seen again) that her story is therefore not consistent(?)
• Christy is then shamed for failing to file police reports (which is quite common for traumatized rape victims - and in any event a report was finally filed with the FBI on her behalf and for her protection here on this website: POLICE REPORTS tab).
  
• Aaron commits a serious "straw-man" (adding words into the other's statement) fallacy by implying Christy has accused "Mike (Rinder), the Headleys, Jackson, yourself, Tom (DeVocht? Cruise?)" of "all colluding to cover up this child rape" - when only a handful of the topmost executives were aware of this and only Mike Rinder is among those very few actually named.  This leaves the reader assuming she has made such a ridiculous charge (which is never cited, since it didn't happen).
• Aaron won't let up on the opportunity he's already seized on, to irresponsibly (or else intentionally) misdirect the viewer to assume Christy has made such a claim, once again repeating the "straw-man" he has created to stand for Christy: "In order to believe what she is saying - in order to entertain it -  you have to also believe that Mike Rinder, Ron Miscavige) Sr., Ron (Miscavige) Jr., Tom DeVocht, Marc & Claire Headley, Jeff Hawkins, Steve Hall - that they have all decided to sit on this and cover up child rape."  - [FALSE! - this straw-man argument is being loudly asserted as what Christy said, in an possible effort to divert attention from the possibility it happened at all.  That Aaron used it so irresponsibly here (he admits that this comes from John McGhee asking her a "loaded question"), regardless of his own frustration with trying to understand the plausibility of her story, is grounds for calling this out as "rape-shaming."]
• "When I say whoever believes this is f@%king nuts, that's what I mean!" - Aaron Smith-Levin - now attempting to shame anyone else who believes her.
• they spend the rest of the show telling stories about "crazy people" including those who were in $cientology who emerged still with "crazy beliefs" as a means to imply that's what Christy suffers from and to pound home that Christy is not to be taken seriously

So Aaron's two shows do not "debunk" anything.  They are loaded with ridiculous assumptions revealing complete ignorance of the conditions at International Base, and the fact that Christy was detained in one room out of view of any staff there, excepting only trusted and bonded security guards, for her entire captivity.

Ridicule and sarcasm is not the way to arrive at the truth of the matter, and directed at a victim of rape, is properly called out for what it is: "RAPE-SHAMING."

Viewers of Aaron's first broadcast were divided.  Some were highly suspicious that David Miscavige could be let off the hook that easily.  Some made the valid demand that Ron (the father) provide a DNA sample to settle the matter of paternity of Christy's two sons.  Yet Ron flatly refused this.

We looked into this refusal as odd, given that Ron had written a book about leaving $cientology and breaking completely with his son, David Miscavige.  Out came legal documents (rounded up by the church, yet still legal testimony and valid documentation) that revealed to us that RAPE RUNS in the MISCAVIGE FAMILY.

1. David Miscavige (as subject of this website)
2. Ron Miscavige, Sr. (document excerpt below)
3. Ron Miscavige, Jr. (letter excerpt below)

(no other males in the family)

---

This is from an "Affidavit of Probable Cause" available in full at https://www.ronmiscavigebook.com/ --- The "probable cause" is for rape charges - more than one.

Speaking of their father, Ron Miscavige, Denise & Lori write, "...he stood by while our oldest brother repeatedly raped us. He enabled and protected that son..."